Skip to: categories | main content

This is What Garden Writing Should Be: Eleanor Perenyi's "Green Thoughts"


Trackbacks

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

Carol said,

Thursday, November 29. 2007 at 21:49 (Link) (Reply)

Colleen... Loved reading your review. I enjoyed this book, too. I feel sometimes alone in gardening in my neighborhood, too and keep my compost bins hidden behind my privacy fence (even though I'm not ashamed of them, it is just better if the neighbors don't know about them!)

The virtual meeting club post will be up late tomorrow.

Carol, May Dreams Gardens

Hi Carol---I hide mine, too. I have some neighbors who are positive that my compost was attracting rats. It was the main reason we put up a privacy fence. Can't wait to read what everyone else has to say!
Kim said,

Thursday, November 29. 2007 at 22:18 (Link) (Reply)

Well, based on that criteria, I have the first principle of gardening down. One need only look at the two boxes worth of spring bulbs I have left to plant to see that I have allowed optimism get the better of my judgement yet again. lol.

Wonderful review, Colleen. This makes me wish I'd played long with the book review this month--here I was thinking that Perenyi wouldn't be so exciting!

Thanks, Kim! I've definitely got the first principle down, as well---looking at all of the seeds in my seed box that I'm planning to wintersow is definitely an exercise in optimism ;-) I was surprised I liked it as much as I did. When I first started looking into it to order it, I thought, "oh, great---another wealthy woman writing about gardening" but it turned out to be a pleasant surprise!
jodi said,

Friday, November 30. 2007 at 17:58 (Link) (Reply)

Great review, Colleen. I too think we're not a vanishing breed, and that for labour-intensive, we could substitute "Stress-relieving"! And optimism is the second necessity of gardening, isn't it? (the first being good soil or enthusiasm...)
Martha said,

Saturday, December 1. 2007 at 00:45 (Link) (Reply)

Perenyi's book was the first of its kind I ever read, too.

Can you imagine being able to write so well. Ahh.

She is still alive and gardening - I wonder if there is any way to contact her and ask her what she thinks now.

Welcome, Martha! Wouldn't that be wonderful? Especially when you consider that she was really ahead of the curve on so many things--like the homogenization of seed stocks and the potential disastrous impact it could have worldwide. We still have that issue, plus the constant debate about GE seed. That is one conversation I'd love to have. Thanks so much for stopping by!
entangled said,

Sunday, December 2. 2007 at 15:46 (Link) (Reply)

So far, as I read the reviews of Green Thoughts, every single one has mentioned how opinionated the author is. But I appreciated the reading and thinking that was so evident behind the opinion, and as you said "her ability to tie gardening into the very heart of our culture". It seemed to me that the either the book had been brewing for a long time, or else she dumped years of notes on her desk and started sorting. Or both.

I wondered too how it all came about. It has to be something like that....I can't imagine anyone being able to just sit down and come up with all of that in a matter of a few months, or even a couple years. The book gave me the impression that Perenyi had been pondering many of the issues in the book for a very long time. It was a fascinating read, for sure!
Mr. McGregor's Daughter said,

Tuesday, December 4. 2007 at 18:55 (Link) (Reply)

It's amazing after reading so many reviews of this book that each blogger has a unique perpective on it. Yours points out how she tied gardening to culture, something I hadn't consciously considered. I think this book came about as thoughts she had while gardening, brewing in her brain for a long time before she finally decided to turn them into a book.
Colleen said,

Wednesday, December 5. 2007 at 09:11 (Link) (Reply)

I think you're probably right about that, MMD. I know that weeding or turning compost gives me plenty of time to reflect on things I don't ordinarily have time to think about. My mind wanders, and ideas come to me. I'd imagine it's the same for most gardeners :-)
Annie in Austin said,

Wednesday, December 5. 2007 at 21:03 (Link) (Reply)

Many of us sort of rejoice in opinionated gardeners, don't we, Colleen, rather than be turned off by their willingness to lay their tastes and prejudices on the line?

The sociological aspects were one reason I was so drawn to her back in the 1980's - and things have not become perfect since then, have they!

I see that you have the newer edition with the flowers on the front cover - if you'd like to see the illustration of the maple tree carved into an outdoor feature [described in the chapter on Tree houses], I've put an enlarged version on my 'extra' blog, Annie's Addendum, so readers can see the engraving that she was talking about.
http://anniesaddendum.blogspot.com/

Annie at the Transplantable Rose

Add Comment

Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA


Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed.